Definition: A tangent chart is defined by the radar method and has a constant, non-physical, Minkowski metric, equal to to the physical metric at an observer’s origin of coordinates.
Coordinate Time and Proper Time
In order to describe geometrical effects we distinguish between physical quantities described in a given coordinate system, by an observer at a distance, and the same quantities as they would be described by a observer who determines them locally. Let Alf be an observer, with a clock at some point,
A, the origin of Alf’s coordinates. Let Beth be a distant observer, with a clock at
B, the origin of Beth’s coordinates. Alf and Beth both determine locally Minkowski coordinates. Alf’s time axis is denoted the 0-axis, and his space axes are labelled
1,
2,
3. Beth’s coordinates are denoted with primes,
0',
1',
2',
3'.
Using general covariance, each observer describes physical quantities using vectors. Using Beth’s primed coodinates, denote the vector describing
t' seconds for a stationary object at the origin of Beth’s coordinates
τ = τi' = (t', 0, 0, 0).
t' is the actual amount of time measured by Beth using her own clock, and is known as
proper time. In Alf’s coordinates,

is found by
coordinate transformation. If Beth is stationary in Alf’s coordinates,
τ = τi' = (kt', 0, 0, 0), where
k is the
gravitational redshift factor.
Stationary Observers
Alf and Beth are stationary with respect to each other and Beth is at a coordinate distance r from Alf as measured in Alf’s coordinates. Alf and Beth each measure the coordinate length of a short rod located at Beth’s origin, and aligned on an axis with Alf and Beth. Using radar, Alf determines that the rod has a coordinate length d, while Beth determines a length d' in her coordinates. Because the rod is at Beth’s origin, d' is the true length, or proper length, of the rod. |
When Alf and Beth try to align their spacetime diagrams, maintaining synchronisation (lines of equal time are horizontal for both) and the constancy of the speed of light (light at 45°), they find a mismatch, because their clocks do not run at the same rate. In the diagrams, Beth’s clock runs faster than Alf’s by a factor k > 1; the arguments also hold when k < 1 and Beth’s clock is slower than Alf’s. Synchronisation requires that, for k > 1, Beth’s coordinates are enlarged by the factor k, so that if Beth’s coordinates are superimposed on Alf’s, and aligned at Beth, Alf appears at a coordinate distance r' = kr, displaced from his position in his own coordinates. |
The diagrams for measurement of the coordinate length of the rod are superimposed. The proper time interval 2d' in Beth’s coordinates corresponds to a time 2kd' in Alf’s coordinates. The proper length d' in Beth’s coordinates appears with coordinate distance d = d'⁄k in Alf’s coordinates. | |
Beth now turns the rod perpendicular to the axis from Alf. Beth calculates that the angle subtended in tangent space by the rod at Alf is θ' = d'/r'. The angle seen by Alf is θ = kθ'. Alf’s coordinate length of the rod,
is equal to its proper length, measured locally by Beth.
==== |
<a name="
TheSpacetimeMetric"></a>The Spacetime Metric====
The <a href="
http://www.teleconnection.info/rqg/IntroductionToVectorSpace#TheMetric»" >metric</a>, <span class="math"><i>g<sub>ij</sub></i>, lowers the indices of <a href="
http://www.teleconnection.info/rqg/IntroductionToTensors#IndexGymnastics»" >contravariant</a> vectors in such a way that the inner product between vectors <span class="math"><i>x</i> and <span class="math"><i>y</i> is an <a href="
http://www.teleconnection.info/rqg/IntroductionToVectorSpace#TheDotProduct»" >invariant</a>,
<img alt="GTR-8" title="The dot product" src="images/gtr/GTR-8.gif" align="texttop" vspace="0">
In particular, the magnitude <span class="math">|<i>x</i>| of the vector <span class="math"><i>x</i> is invariant,
<img alt="GTR-9" title="vector magnitude" src="images/gtr/GTR-9.gif" align="texttop" vspace="0">
so that the metric is a means of determining magnitude of a vector in any coordinate system.
The laws of physics local to Beth, as described by Beth, use proper times and distances determined in her local measurements. If Alf is to analyse physical processes close to Beth, he must also determine proper times and distances, using remote measurements. The definition of the metric ensures that, when Alf applies it to his own measurements, the magnitudes returned will be the proper times and distances of quantities local to Beth. General relativity allows that, in principle, Beth could be anywhere in Alf’s coordinate space. For each point, <span class="math"><i>x</i>, where Beth could be, there is a different metric, <span class="math"><i>g<sub>ij</sub></i>(<i>x</i>)</i>.
<<span class="math"><b>Definition:</b> ; The metric field is defined, on a given coordinate system, by
<img alt="GTR-12g" title="The metric field is a function on spacetime coordinates" src="images/gtr/GTR-12g.gif" align="texttop" vspace="0">
The metric field is often simply called the metric. Care should be taken. Failure to distinguish the metric at a given coordinate from the metric field as a function of coordinate space can lead to confusion.
We have just seen that for quantities local to Beth, measured, or coordinate, time <span class="math">2<i>kd'</i> in Alf’s coordinates corresponds to a proper time <span class="math">2<i>d', that coordinate distance <span class="math"><i>d' ⁄ k corresponds to a proper distance <span class="math"><i>d', and that angular distances are unchanged. Thus, a simple form for <span class="math"><i>g can be given in <a href=
http://www.teleconnection.info/rqg/IntroductionToVectorSpace#SphericalCoordinates>spherical» coordinates</a>,
<img alt="GTR-10" title="Covariant components of the metric for mutually stationary observers" src="images/gtr/GTR-10.gif" align="texttop" vspace="0">
The [[http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Schwarzschild_metric Schwarzschild]] solution to Einstein’s field equations for static coordinates, outside of an isolated spherically symmetric gravitating body is an example of a metric with this form, in which
<img alt="GTR-11" title="k in Schwarzschild coordinates" src="images/gtr/GTR-11.gif" align="texttop" vspace="0">
These forms of the metric, <span class="math"><i>g, are coordinate dependent. The metric is a [[introductionToTensors tensor]] quantity, and will be used in tensor equations. Tensor equations are <a href="
http://www.teleconnection.info/rqg/IntroductionToTensors#ThePrincipleOfGeneralCovariance»" >covariant</a>, so that if a tensor equation holds in one set of coordinates, then it will hold in any coordinates. In particular, a tensor equation will hold after a <a href=
IntroductionToVectorSpace#
CoordinateTransformation">Lorentz transform</a> of either Alf’s or Beth’s coordinates, so the choice of stationary observers places no limitation on generality.
====<a name="
TheLevi-
CivitaConnection"></a>The Levi-Civita Connection====
The metric field is a measure of the distortion present in a chart. It is not sufficient to describe curvature — we have seen examples of distorted spaces, like the <a href=
BasicsOfCurvature#Lens>lensed and mirrored </a> geometries, which are actually flat. To describe curvature requires a <a href=
http://www.teleconnection.info/rqg/GeneralRelativity#http://www.teleconnection.info/rqg/BasicsOfCurvature#ParallelDisplacement>connection</a>"»" in addition to the metric field. Given the metric field, an
affine connection» describes a relationship between a set of coordinate axes at
x, say, and another set, at
x +dx, where
dx is a small displacement, such that we can meaningfully describe a vector at
x as being parallel to one at
x +dx (other types of
connection» are used to transport other types of data).
In general relativity the connection is defined in the same way as in the surface of the Earth. That is to say, it is defined between vectors at nearby points using
parallel displacement in tangent space, and projecting back into the curved surface. This is the
Levi-Civita connection», defined in accordance with physical experience, that it makes sense to translate objects in space through small distances. As with Earth geometry, a relationship between coordinates at distant points can only be determined through
parallel transport, and is path dependent. Other affine connections are mathematically possible. For example, if rectangular coordinates were superimposed on the image in a convex mirror or a lens, the geometry would have an affine connection such that the apparently curved space is actually flat. Such connections do not appear to be physically interesting.
Einstein was not satisfied that the Levi-Civita connection is physically correct. He observed an inconsistency between general relativity and classical electromagnetism. Such an inconsistency can be seen in the mismatch of Alf’s and Beth’s coordinates. Light emitted from the end of the short rod and seen by Beth does not behave in the same way as light emitted from the same point, in the same direction, and seen by Alf — if it did, Alf’s coordinate length would be altered by the same factor as his coordinate time rather than by the inverse factor, and space would have to be flat. The inconsistency lead Einstein to investigate a different form of parallelism which he called distant parallelism, also known as
teleparallelism». The possibility of such a connection had previously been pointed out by
Cartan», known as the best geometer in Europe, and who was the first to recognise the distinct roles of the connection and the metric in the description of curvature.
Einstein’s attempts at unification of general relativity and classical electromagnetism using teleparallelism failed. The teleconnection in relational quantum gravity seeks to unify general relativity with quantum electrodynamics and uses a different form of distant parallelism, one rooted in a philosophical issue also raised by Einstein. The
hole argument» gave him considerable trouble in his original formulation of general relativity. In general relativity, the metric is defined at all points in space. Empirically, spacetime coordinates can only be defined in the presence of matter. It is physically meaningless to define a metric when there is nothing to be measured, as in the vacuum of space. The teleconnection will describe a relationship between coordinate axes, at remote points,
x and
y, such that we can meaningfully translate momentum from
x to
y, and such that the Levi-Civita connection is restored in the limit of small displacement between
x and
y.
Concepts of General Relativity ↑ Riemann Curvature →